Article | . 2018 Vol. 36, Issue. 2
Physical and Chemical Properties of Bottom Ash and Coir Dust Mix Used as Horticultural Substrates



Department of Horticulture and Forestry, Pai Chai Univer1
Department of Biosystems and Biotechnology, Korea University2
Department of Horticultural Sciences, Chungnam National University3
Division of Biotechnology, Korea University4




2018.. 161:171


PDF XML




This study evaluated the use of bottom ash as a root medium component when mixed with coir dust in different ratios. Each of two kinds of bottom ash (coarse bottom ash, CBA, with particle size ≥ 5 mm; and fine bottom ash, FBA, with particle size ≥ 5 mm) were mixed with coir dust in the ratios 10:0, 9:1, 8:2, 7:3, 6:4, 5:5, and 0:10 (coir dust:bottom ash, v/v). We investigated the physical properties of mixed substrates, i.e., particle size distribution, container capacity, air space, total porosity, bulk density, and the moisture retention curve; and chemical properties, i.e., pH, electrical conductivity, and nutrient content. Large particles (1.4-5.6 mm in diameter) increased as the ratio of CBA increased, while small particles (< 710 μm in diameter) increased as the ratio of coir dust increased. As the ratio of FBA increased, small particles (< 106 μm) increased. As CBA increased, the container capacity decreased but air spaces increased, while increasing FBA reduced the air spaces in the substrate mix. In 100% FBA medium, the maximum container capacity was low (32.5%), and had very low easily available water (below 2%); this suggests that, on its own, FBA has poor potential for use as a horticultural medium. In substrate mixes of acidic coir dust (pH 4.99) and CBA, increasing the proportion of bottom ash gradually increased the pH, which is similar to perlite. Electrical conductivity of the substrate increased as the ratio of FBA in the substrate mix increased, largely caused by the high Ca and Na content of FBA. When the proportion of FBA was increased in the substrate mix by more than 30%, Cd contents were higher than the acceptable level for use in horticulture. Other heavy metals (As, Pb, Cr, Cu, Ni, and Zn) were detected at low concentrations in all substrate mixes, but within the acceptable range for use in horticultural media. Based on these results, bottom ash may be used as a component of horticultural media, but to maintain physical and chemical properties within acceptable limits it is not recommended to exceed 20% of the mixture.



1. Bardhan S, Chen Y, Dick WA (2009) Recycling for sustainability: plant growth media from coal combustion products, biosolids and compost. Int J Environ Sci Eng 1:176-182  

2. Bearce BC (1998) Coal bottom ash as a component of floriculture root media. HortScience 33:203-203  

3. Bilderback TE, Fonteno WC, Johnson DR (1982) Physical properties of media composed of peanut hulls, pine bark, and peatmoss and their effects on azalea growth. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 107:522-525  

4. Black BL, Zimmerman RH (2002) Mixtures of coal ash and compost as substrates for highbush blueberry. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 127:869-877  

5. Bruder-Hubscher V, Lagarde F, Leroy MJF, Coughanowr C, Enguehard F (2001) Utilisation of bottom ash in road construction: evaluation of the environmental impact. Waste Manag Res 19:545-556, doi.org/10.1177/0734242X0101900611  

6. Bunt AC (1988) Media and mixes for container grown plants: a manual on the preparation and use of growing media for growing pot plants. Unwyn Hyman, London, UK. doi.org/10.1007/978-94-011-7904-1  

7. Butler SH, Bearce BC (1995) Greenhouse rose production in media containing coal bottom ash. J Environ Hortic 13:160-163  

8. Cary EE, Gilbert M, Bache CA, Gutenmann WH, Lisk DJ (1983) Elemental composition of potted vegetables and millet grown on hard coal bottom ash-amended soil. Bul Environ Contam Toxicol 31:418-423, doi.org/10.1007/BF01622271  

9. Choi JM, Kim LY, Kim B-G (2009) Soilless Substrates. Hakyesa, Daejeon, Korea  

10. Engstrom KB, Myers SG, Bearce BC (1994) Growth and flowering responses of 'Dark Red Hegg' poinsettias in coal ash-amended root media to 3 nutrient solutions in a closed-loop nutriculture system. HortScience 29:452-452  

11. Evans MR, Buck JS, Sambo P (2011) The pH, electrical conductivity, and primary macronutrient concentration of sphagnum peat and ground parboiled fresh rice hull substrates over time in a greenhouse environment. HortTechnology 21:103-108  

12. Jackson BE, Wright RD, Browder JF, Harris JR, Niemiera AX (2008) Effect of fertilizer rate on growth of azalea and holly in pine bark and pine tree substrates. HortScience 43:1561-1568  

13. Jackson BE, Wright RD, Seiler JR (2009) Changes in chemical and physical properties of pine tree substrate and pine bark during long-term nursery crop production. HortScience 44:791-799  

14. Kim IS, Li X-R, Yun HK, Kim YD, Shin KC, Yoo KC (2001) Development of hydroponic substrates using coal fly ash. Hortic Environ Biotechnol 42:171-176  

15. Kim YK, Lee SJ, Shin MH, Lee SR, Lee YS (2010) Comparison of geotechnical characteristics of bottom ash for lightweight fill material. In KGS Spring National Conference 2010. Korean Geotechnical Society, Gyeonggi, Korea, pp 25-26  

16. Li X-R, Jeong CS, Kim IS, Yoo KC (2000) Effects of limited amount of nutrient solution suppling during fruit ripening stage on growth and sugar content of musk melon fruit in coal fly ash ball substrate culture. Korean J Hortic Sci Technol 18:685 (Suppl II)  

17. Li X-R, Kang WS, Yoo KC, Kim IS (2001a) Development of nutrient solution for tomato culture utilizing coal fly ash ball substrate by comparing the water and nutrient uptake characteristics. Hortic Environ Biotechnol 42:11-16  

18. Li X-R, Kang WS, Yoo KC, Kim IS (2001b) Physical and chemical properties of coal fly ash ball substrates, the salt accumulation and the effects of washing out salt with water. J Bio-Environ Control 10:88-94  

19. Milks RR, Fonteno WC, Larson RA (1989) Hydrology of horticultural substrates. II. Predicting physical properties of media in containers. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 114:53-56  

20. Myers SS, Bearce B (1993) Growth and flowering response of 'Brilliant Diamond' poinsettias in a peat vermiculite mix amended with coal bottom ash. HortScience 28:256  

21. Olszewski MW, Eisenman SW (2017) Influence of biochar amendment on herb growth in a green roof substrate. Hortic Environ Biotechnol 58: 406-413  

22. Pitchay DS, Bearce BC (1996a) Chemical and physical properties of coal bottom ash-based root media and their effect on poinsettia nutritive status, growth, and flowering. HortScience 31:912  

23. Pitchay DS, Bearce BC (1996b) Growth of petunia, impatiens, and ivy and zonal geraniums in root media containing coal bottom ash. HortScience 31:915  

24. Pitchay DS, Myers S, Bearce BC (1998) Dry weight partitioning among roots, shoot bottoms and tops, and leaves of Hydrangea macrophylla cuttings rooted in coal bottom ash or peat: perlite media containing four levels of dolomitic limestone. HortScience 33:465  

25. Pitchay DS, Sherratt MD, Bearce BC (1996) Inflorescence color manipulation in hydrangea forced in media containing coal bottom ash and mine soil. HortScience 31:658  

26. RDA (2012) Standard of research methods and analysis for agricultural science. Rural Development Administration, Jeonju, Korea  

27. RDA (2013) Official standard of commercial fertilizer. Rural Development Administration, Jeonju, Korea  

28. Richards D, Lane M, Beardsell DV (1986) The influence of particle-size distribution in pinebark: sand: brown coal potting mixes on water supply, aeration and plant growth. Sci Hortic 29:1-14, doi.org/10.1016/0304-4238(86)90025-7  

29. Schlossberg MJ, Miller WP (2004) Coal combustion by-product (CCB) utilization in turfgrass sod production. HortScience 39:408-414  

30. Shin S, Kumar S, Jung T, Shin B (2007) The strength and characteristic of PCC bottom ash. J Korean Geo-Environ Soc 8:57-63  

31. Taerakul P, Lamminen M, Walker H, Harold EE (2002) Water quality at Roberts Dawson mine following injection of flue gas desulfurization by-product. In 223rd ACS National Meeting. Am Chemical Soc, Orlando, FL, pp 7-11  

32. Wallach R, Da Silva FF, Chen Y (1992) Unsaturated hydraulic characteristics of composted agricultural wastes, tuff, and their mixtures. Soil Sci 153:434-441. doi.org/10.1097/00010694-199206000-00002  

33. Wang Y-T (2007) Potassium nutrition affects Phalaenopsis growth and flowering. HortScience 42:1563-1567  

34. Warncke DD (1986) Analyzing greenhouse growth media by the saturation extraction method. HortScience 21:223-225  

35. Woodard M, Bearce B, Cluskey S, Townsend E (1993) Coal bottom ash and pine wood peelings as root substrates in a circulating nutriculture system. HortScience 28:636-638